SEARCH FOR HOMES

SEARCH FOR HOMES

Open Houses: Thursday April 23rd 5:30-7
Saturday April 25th 12-2

A Piece of Geneva’s Story—With Space to Live It

If you’ve been searching for homes for sale in Geneva NY that offer more than just a standard layout, this one stands apart.

Built in 1870 and set on a rare 0.73-acre wooded lot within the city, this 3-bedroom, 2-bath home brings together history, space, and everyday livability in a way that’s increasingly hard to find.

A Setting That Feels Different

It’s not just the home, it’s the land.

With nearly three-quarters of an acre, the property offers:

  • A wooded backdrop for added privacy
  • Space to garden, entertain, or simply spread out
  • A setting that feels removed, while still being in the city

 

For buyers looking at Geneva NY real estate, this kind of lot is not typical.

It’s the kind of setting where:

  • Mornings begin on the porch with coffee
  • Evenings stretch a little longer outside
  • Weekends don’t require leaving home to feel like a break

Inside: Character You Can Feel, Layout That Works

With over 2,000 square feet, the home offers flexibility for how people live today—without losing its original charm.

Highlights:

  • Hardwood floors throughout most of the home (excluding kitchen and bathrooms)
  • First-floor primary bedroom
  • First-floor laundry
  • Dedicated den or home office
  • Heated sunroom for year-round use
  • Welcoming foyer/entry space

 

The layout gives you options—whether you need work-from-home space, first-floor living, or simply room to move comfortably day to day.

The Updates That Matter

While the home carries its history, there are important updates and systems already in place:

  • Metal roof (approximately 10 years old)
  • Central air and forced air heat (gas) (approximately 8 years old)
  • Electric heat pump hot water heater (1 year old)
  • Public water and sewer connections
  • 150-amp electric service with circuit breakers
  • Full basement with exterior walk-up access

 

These are the kinds of details that support daily comfort while preserving the home’s original charm.

Storage, Flexibility, and Everyday Convenience

  • 2-car attached garage
  • Double-wide driveway
  • Additional shed for storage or hobbies

 

Whether you need space for tools, projects, or simply extra storage, the property gives you options without compromise.

Living in Geneva

Located on a neighborhood street in the City of Geneva, you’re close to everything that makes this area appealing—from local shops and dining to the Finger Lakes region just beyond.

It’s a location that offers:

  • A strong sense of community
  • Easy access to daily essentials
  • Proximity to water, wineries, and seasonal events
  • The balance of city convenience and nearby natural beauty

A Note on History

Built in the late 1800s, this home reflects a time when craftsmanship and longevity mattered.

Owning a home like this isn’t just about square footage—it’s about carrying forward a piece of Geneva’s history while making it your own.

What to Notice When You Visit

When you walk through, pay attention to:

  • How the natural light moves through the sunroom
  • The flow between living spaces and first-floor bedroom
  • The depth and privacy of the lot—it feels different in person
  • The consistency of hardwood flooring throughout the main living areas

 

These are the details that don’t always show up in photos—but matter once you’re inside.

Check out the 3-D Tour Below

Digital Brouchure

Frequently Asked Questions About 21 Jay Street Geneva

The home was built in 1870, giving it over 150 years of history. It reflects the character and craftsmanship of its era while offering updates that support modern living.

The property sits on approximately 0.73 acres, which is considered a generous lot size for a home located within the City of Geneva.

The home includes:

  • 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms
  • A first-floor primary bedroom
  • First-floor laundry
  • A den or office space
  • A heated sunroom

This layout offers flexibility for a variety of living arrangements.

The home is connected to:

  • Public water and sewer
  • Gas forced air heating with central air conditioning
  • 150-amp electrical service with circuit breakers

These systems support everyday comfort and functionality.

Yes, the home features a metal roof that is approximately 10 years old, according to the seller’s disclosure.

Yes, the property includes:

  • A 2-car attached garage
  • A double-wide driveway

There is also additional storage available with a shed.

The combination of:

  • A large, wooded lot within the city
  • A home with historical character
  • A flexible interior layout

…creates a setting that is not commonly found in this price range or location.

Spotted me around town?

Curious what your home might be worth in today’s market? You can get a personalized report sent to you.

You’ll enter your email to receive the report. I won’t reach out unless you ask me to.